Fighting against Raccoon eyes one make-up remover at a time

Ok, so I’ll admit it, I’m really lazy when it comes to removing my makeup at the end of the day.  Especially if I have gone out and indulged in a few cocktails before calling it a night!  I’m forever waking up with mascara/eyeliner marks on my pillow cases or getting out of the shower and leaving black on my white towels. 

I like dark liquid liner, lots of mascara and shouldn’t be punished for it.  Furthermore, despite being admittedly lazy, I should not have to spend 10min and oodles of cotton to get it off properly.  With this in mind I’ve gone out and tests 3 different types of eye makeup removers all while using White Towels and White Sheet/Pillow cases (thank goodness for bleach).

The Body Shop’s Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover

The Good:

  • Takes off all my heavy makeup with 2 cotton pads and with very little time and effort
  • Doesn’t leave a greasy residue therefore can be easily used to touch up makeup smears throughout the day without having to reapply your whole look
  • Very affordable price

The Not So Good:

  • I found I needed to use a lot of the product per cotton pad (really soak it) to get all my make up off

Overall Impressions: This product is the one I liked the best out of the 3 I’m reviewing and it has become a staple in my gym bag for my after workout shower routine.  My towels and sheets remain smuge free and although I do have to use lots of product it is still a really reasonable price (especially when there are sales!)

Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

The Good:

  • It’s Oil Free so if you suffer from acne or oily skin this is perfect for you
  • You doen’t need to rub to get the makeup off, dabbing will work just fine

The Not So Good:

  • It’s oily free but my eyes still felt greasy afterwards so there’s no way I’d use this product to touch up any make up smudges
  • Takes a long time to get all the eye makeup off – resulting in a fail grade in my white sheets and towels test

Overall Impressions: It’s an OK eye makeup remover.  If you don’t use heavy eye make up and/or have oily skin and are able to invest the 10min to getting all the makeup off then you shouldn’t have any issues. 

Almay Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover Pads

The Good:

  • Pre-soaked pads make it easier to remove your eye makeup and to carry it around in your bag
  • No greasy residue was left behind
  • With my lazy ways I managed to get 80% of my eye makeup off

The Not So Good:

  • With 10% of makeup still lingering Almay failed my sheets and towel test
  • Pre-soaked pads doesn’t make it as conducive to touching up smudges
  • Had to rub to get off my makeup and my eyes felt scratchy and a bit raw afterwards

Overall Impressions:  All though Almay provides a no fuss no mess alternative I’m still not convinced this is a good option.  This was my least preferred of the 3 I tested.  I think this would be good for someone who wears very little eye makeup and isn’t good for people like myself who tend to wear heavier dark eye makeup.


This entry was posted in Beauty and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s